Had this conversation at work and there seems to be a struggle between Paul & John. I know George is a good writer also but who do you think? I've sided with Paul coz I liked more of his songs post beatleism See how it packs up here.
Posted by chaz36 (Member # 21412) on :
McCartney
Posted by Talos (Member # 39913) on :
Juice... Beetlejuice. lol
Posted by toelovingman (Member # 1180) on :
John
Posted by solesguy (Member # 48795) on :
George Harrison is very underrated imo. I still can't believe John crafted some of those songs as they are absolutely brilliant. The most talented? Paul can do anything so I would have to say Paul. (we will never see a band like that again)
Posted by Cain (Member # 8492) on :
I'm kind of partial to John
Posted by Toetapper (Member # 6473) on :
Not to take away from the others, I'm leaning toward Paul. Though it is difficult to sort out who actually wrote what, the Lennon & McCartney collaboration was the monster.
I wish I could get posting images right; great photo of John & Paul at an interview with the press (I admit I'm old enough I remember this):
Press: "Is Ringo the best drummer in the world?"
Response: "Ringo isn't the best drummer in the Beatles".
![[Smile]](smile.gif)
See how it packs up here.